This is my new favorite makeup thing. (I’m still slowly working through the haul of e.l.f. makeup I got a while back when they were running an insane 50% off everything sale.) This is an eyeliner/shadow stick ($3) and I got it in smoke/black. I’m going to buy it in all other color combos soon. I use the shadow side along both lash lines and then blend until it’s so soft you can barely see it—just a light wash of grayish silver on my eyes. I can add mascara at this point and be done…or for a smokier eye, line my waterlines with the eyeliner and blend again.